Why This Comparison Matters
SB 35 (Wiener, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017) and SB 423 (Wiener, Chapter 778, Statutes of 2023) both amend the same code section — Government Code § 65913.4 — and both create a ministerial approval pathway for qualifying multifamily housing near transit. But SB 423 did not replace SB 35. Instead, it amended and dramatically expanded § 65913.4, extending the sunset date, eliminating the coastal zone exclusion, and adjusting labor standards.
The practical effect: for projects submitted after January 1, 2024, the operative law is § 65913.4 as amended by SB 423.
Statute Overview
| Provision | SB 35 (2017–2023) | SB 423 (2024–2036) |
|---|---|---|
| Bill / Chaptered | SB 35, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017 | SB 423, Chapter 778, Statutes of 2023 |
| Code Section | Government Code § 65913.4 (enacted) | Government Code § 65913.4 (amended) |
| Effective Date | January 1, 2018 | January 1, 2024 |
| Sunset Date | January 1, 2026 (original) | January 1, 2036 |
| CEQA Treatment | Ministerial — CEQA-exempt | Same |
| Approval Type | Ministerial — no public hearing | Same |
Coastal Zone Applicability
| Provision | SB 35 | SB 423 |
|---|---|---|
| Coastal zone projects | Excluded entirely | Included — with additional affordability thresholds |
| Coastal Permit (CDP) | N/A (excluded) | Still required in addition to ministerial approval |
| Higher affordability for coastal | N/A | RHNA-compliant cities: ≥ 60% affordable; non-compliant: ≥ 2/3 |
Affordability Thresholds
| Jurisdiction Status | SB 35 | SB 423 (Non-Coastal) | SB 423 (Coastal Zone) |
|---|---|---|---|
| RHNA compliant | ≥ 50% affordable | ≥ 50% affordable | ≥ 60% affordable |
| Not meeting RHNA | ≥ 2/3 affordable | ≥ 2/3 affordable | ≥ 2/3 affordable |
Site Eligibility Criteria
| Eligibility Criterion | SB 35 | SB 423 |
|---|---|---|
| Zoning requirement | Residential or mixed-use with ≥ 2/3 residential | Same |
| Transit proximity | Within ½ mile of major transit stop | Same |
| Urbanized area | Required | Same |
| Fire hazard zone | Excluded | Same |
| Coastal zone | Excluded entirely | Included (with higher affordability) |
Labor Standards
| Labor Requirement | SB 35 | SB 423 |
|---|---|---|
| Skilled and trained workforce | Required for all qualifying projects | Same |
| Prevailing wages | 50+ unit projects | Same |
| Healthcare coverage | Not required | New — 50+ unit projects must provide qualifying healthcare |
Enforcement and Penalties
| Enforcement Mechanism | SB 35 | SB 423 |
|---|---|---|
| Enforcement statute | HAA (GC § 65589.5) | Same |
| Remedy for unlawful denial | Writ of mandate | Same |
| Attorney fees | Awarded to prevailing applicant | Uncapped under SB 1037 |
| Per-unit civil penalties | Up to $10,000/unit | SB 1037 tiered: $10K / $20K / $50K per unit |
Decision Tree: Which Statute Applies?
For applications submitted after January 1, 2024, use § 65913.4 as amended by SB 423:
- Is the site zoned for residential or mixed use (≥ 2/3 residential)?
- Is the site within ½ mile of a major transit stop?
- Is the site in an urbanized area?
- Does the site meet all negative eligibility criteria?
- Is the site in the coastal zone? (If yes: higher affordability threshold + CDP required)
- What is the jurisdiction's RHNA compliance status?
- Does the project meet the applicable affordability threshold?
Key Takeaway for Planning Departments
- Coastal zone: All qualifying coastal zone projects submitted after January 1, 2024 must be processed ministerially.
- Healthcare requirement: Contractors on 50+ unit projects must now certify qualifying healthcare coverage.
- Sunset extended to 2036: Ministerial approval pathways under § 65913.4 are operative through January 1, 2036.
This report is prepared by Legislaide, Inc. for informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice.
Prepared by Legislaide — legislaide.com
Part of the 2025 California Legislative Guide Series for Cities
© 2026 Legislaide Incorporated. All rights reserved.