Back to guides
    California GuidesApril 2026

    SB 35 vs. SB 423: A Side-by-Side Comparison of California's Ministerial Housing Approval Statutes

    Reference Guide | Operative Law: Government Code § 65913.4 as amended by SB 423

    Why This Comparison Matters

    SB 35 (Wiener, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017) and SB 423 (Wiener, Chapter 778, Statutes of 2023) both amend the same code section — Government Code § 65913.4 — and both create a ministerial approval pathway for qualifying multifamily housing near transit. But SB 423 did not replace SB 35. Instead, it amended and dramatically expanded § 65913.4, extending the sunset date, eliminating the coastal zone exclusion, and adjusting labor standards.

    The practical effect: for projects submitted after January 1, 2024, the operative law is § 65913.4 as amended by SB 423.


    Statute Overview

    ProvisionSB 35 (2017–2023)SB 423 (2024–2036)
    Bill / ChapteredSB 35, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017SB 423, Chapter 778, Statutes of 2023
    Code SectionGovernment Code § 65913.4 (enacted)Government Code § 65913.4 (amended)
    Effective DateJanuary 1, 2018January 1, 2024
    Sunset DateJanuary 1, 2026 (original)January 1, 2036
    CEQA TreatmentMinisterial — CEQA-exemptSame
    Approval TypeMinisterial — no public hearingSame

    Coastal Zone Applicability

    ProvisionSB 35SB 423
    Coastal zone projectsExcluded entirelyIncluded — with additional affordability thresholds
    Coastal Permit (CDP)N/A (excluded)Still required in addition to ministerial approval
    Higher affordability for coastalN/ARHNA-compliant cities: ≥ 60% affordable; non-compliant: ≥ 2/3

    Affordability Thresholds

    Jurisdiction StatusSB 35SB 423 (Non-Coastal)SB 423 (Coastal Zone)
    RHNA compliant≥ 50% affordable≥ 50% affordable≥ 60% affordable
    Not meeting RHNA≥ 2/3 affordable≥ 2/3 affordable≥ 2/3 affordable

    Site Eligibility Criteria

    Eligibility CriterionSB 35SB 423
    Zoning requirementResidential or mixed-use with ≥ 2/3 residentialSame
    Transit proximityWithin ½ mile of major transit stopSame
    Urbanized areaRequiredSame
    Fire hazard zoneExcludedSame
    Coastal zoneExcluded entirelyIncluded (with higher affordability)

    Labor Standards

    Labor RequirementSB 35SB 423
    Skilled and trained workforceRequired for all qualifying projectsSame
    Prevailing wages50+ unit projectsSame
    Healthcare coverageNot requiredNew — 50+ unit projects must provide qualifying healthcare

    Enforcement and Penalties

    Enforcement MechanismSB 35SB 423
    Enforcement statuteHAA (GC § 65589.5)Same
    Remedy for unlawful denialWrit of mandateSame
    Attorney feesAwarded to prevailing applicantUncapped under SB 1037
    Per-unit civil penaltiesUp to $10,000/unitSB 1037 tiered: $10K / $20K / $50K per unit

    Decision Tree: Which Statute Applies?

    For applications submitted after January 1, 2024, use § 65913.4 as amended by SB 423:

    1. Is the site zoned for residential or mixed use (≥ 2/3 residential)?
    2. Is the site within ½ mile of a major transit stop?
    3. Is the site in an urbanized area?
    4. Does the site meet all negative eligibility criteria?
    5. Is the site in the coastal zone? (If yes: higher affordability threshold + CDP required)
    6. What is the jurisdiction's RHNA compliance status?
    7. Does the project meet the applicable affordability threshold?

    Key Takeaway for Planning Departments

    • Coastal zone: All qualifying coastal zone projects submitted after January 1, 2024 must be processed ministerially.
    • Healthcare requirement: Contractors on 50+ unit projects must now certify qualifying healthcare coverage.
    • Sunset extended to 2036: Ministerial approval pathways under § 65913.4 are operative through January 1, 2036.

    This report is prepared by Legislaide, Inc. for informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice.

    Prepared by Legislaide — legislaide.com

    Part of the 2025 California Legislative Guide Series for Cities

    © 2026 Legislaide Incorporated. All rights reserved.

    All guides

    Published by Legal @ Legislaide