What SB 1037 Changes
SB 1037 (Skinner, Chapter 654, Statutes of 2024) amended Government Code § 65589.5 — the Housing Accountability Act — to dramatically increase civil penalties for cities that unlawfully deny or impose conditions that would reduce the density of qualifying housing projects. The bill took effect January 1, 2025 and created a new enforcement regime that city attorneys must understand before the next contested housing denial.
The prior HAA imposed maximum civil penalties of $10,000 per housing unit affected by an unlawful denial. SB 1037 created a tiered penalty structure that replaces this flat cap:
- Baseline penalty: Up to $10,000 per unit, as before.
- Elevated penalty for second violations: Up to $20,000 per unit if the jurisdiction has been found in violation of the HAA within the prior 5 years.
- Willful violation penalty: Up to $50,000 per unit if the court finds the violation was willful.
Additionally, SB 1037 removed the attorney fee cap that previously limited what a prevailing applicant could recover. Attorney fee awards are now uncapped and mandatory for HAA prevailing applicants.
Who This Matters To In City Hall
| Role | Why This Matters to You |
|---|---|
| City Attorney | A 100-unit project denied on grounds a court finds willfully violating the HAA now carries up to $5 million in penalties plus uncapped attorney fees. |
| City Manager | Elected officials directing staff to deny qualifying projects are now directing the city toward potentially catastrophic financial liability. |
| Planning Director | HAA findings for any denial must now be documented in the staff report with specificity. |
| City Council | Council members who direct staff to deny housing on grounds not supported by HAA-required findings create willfulness exposure for the city. |
| Finance Director | HAA penalty exposure should now appear in city risk assessments and budget reserve analysis. |
Legislation Overview
SB 1037 (Skinner) | Chapter 654, Statutes of 2024 | Signed: September 28, 2024 | Effective: January 1, 2025 | Amends: Government Code § 65589.5
The Willfulness Standard
The most consequential addition in SB 1037 is the $50,000-per-unit willfulness penalty. Under the statutory language, a violation is willful if the city "acted with knowledge that its conduct violated" the HAA "or in reckless disregard of the legal requirements." California courts will look at:
- Whether city counsel advised that the denial may violate the HAA — and the city denied anyway
- Whether the city had been found in violation of the HAA in prior proceedings
- Whether the denial findings were conclusory, pretextual, or unsupported by the administrative record
- Whether the city imposed procedural delays that had the effect of preventing approval
- Whether the council was responding to neighbor opposition rather than a documented health/safety basis
The HCD Referral Pathway
SB 1037 also strengthened HCD's referral authority. Applicants who believe a city has unlawfully denied or delayed a qualifying housing project may now refer the matter to HCD, which has the authority to review the denial and refer the matter to the Attorney General if it finds a violation.
What Has NOT Changed
Cities may still deny a qualifying housing project if they make written findings that:
- The project would have a specific, adverse impact upon public health or safety that cannot feasibly be mitigated or avoided; or
- The project is inconsistent with objective, written, and duly adopted standards in effect when the application was deemed complete.
Compliance Risk Assessment
| Risk | Level | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Denying a qualifying project without HAA-required findings | HIGH | Mandatory writ of mandate; up to $50,000/unit in penalties; uncapped attorney fees. |
| Denying after receiving legal advice that denial violates HAA | HIGH | Strong evidence of willfulness; $50,000/unit exposure. |
| Second HAA violation within 5 years | HIGH | $20,000/unit penalty at minimum. |
| Conclusory or unsupported denial findings | MEDIUM | Insufficient findings create evidence of willfulness. |
| Procedural delays on qualifying projects | MEDIUM | May constitute a de facto denial. |
Key Dates
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| September 28, 2024 | Governor signs SB 1037 |
| January 1, 2025 | New penalty tiers and uncapped attorney fees take effect |
| Current (2026) | All HAA denials since January 1, 2025 are subject to new penalty regime |
Action Checklist
Immediate — Complete Now
- City Attorney: Prepare a memo for council summarizing the SB 1037 penalty tiers before any contested housing project comes to a vote.
- City Attorney: Review any housing denial issued since January 1, 2025 for HAA compliance.
- Planning Director: Require that all staff reports recommending denial include specific, documented findings.
Near-Term — By June 30, 2026
- City Attorney: Develop a housing denial checklist for planning staff and commission.
- City Manager: Incorporate HAA penalty exposure into the city's risk management program.
- Planning Director: Train planning commissioners on the SB 1037 penalty regime.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do the new penalties apply to denials before January 1, 2025?
No. The new penalty tiers apply to violations occurring on or after January 1, 2025.
Who collects the civil penalties?
HAA civil penalties are imposed by the superior court as part of a writ of mandate proceeding.
What if the council overrides the planning department's recommendation and denies the project on political grounds?
This is exactly the scenario SB 1037 is designed to reach. A council denial that contradicts a staff recommendation of approval creates strong willfulness evidence.
This report is prepared by Legislaide, Inc. for informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice.
Prepared by Legislaide — legislaide.com
Part of the 2025 California Legislative Guide Series for Cities
© 2026 Legislaide Incorporated. All rights reserved.